A Simple Clothing System Supplemental: Wind Shells as Semipermeable Vapor Barriers

Which is to say, how should you use your wind shell to layer for cold conditions? The answer is not what I thought it was…

Wife: “Did you buy a book called Extreme Alpinism?”

Me: “Yes…?”

Wife: “Why?”

A legitimate question, considering that the closest thing to alpinism that I see these days is climbing the stairs by Bass Pro Shop on my morning dog walks. In fact, I can’t say that I’ve ever done alpinism of any sort, aside from some rock climbing in the Winds years ago. Why, on earth do I need a copy of Mark Twight’s treatise on radical lightweight alpine-style climbing?

“I need it for my research library…”

Closest I’ve ever come to alpinism.

Truth be told, I’ve wanted a copy for a long time, primarily to read Twight’s take on layering systems. I finally found a used ex-library copy (Boulder Public Library, that’s pretty cool) at a good price and snapped it up.

Twight popularized the use of fully breathable clothing systems for cold weather, contributed to the development of Patagonia’s Regulator layering system, and was instrumental in creating an advanced layering system for the special operations community, which eventually morphed into the Army’s modern cold weather uniform. The guy is the master.

And he’s a great writer. Twight has a brooding, Gen X style and sardonic wit that earned him the nickname “Doctor Doom.” His collection of climbing essays in Kiss or Kill is essential armchair mountaineer reading.

The guy can write.

So, of course I wanted to read Extreme Alpinism. In particular I was curious about the idea of wearing a wind shell deep within a layering system to create a “pseudo vapor barrier.” I’ve tried vapor barriers in the past, with mixed results, but this sounded like something different. Something better.

Vapor Barriers
Back when I got started in the outdoor business, the undisputed bible of backpacking was Colin Fletcher’s The Complete Walker. Fletcher was an author and adventurer who had racked up thousands of miles on impressive backcountry trips. And written bestselling travelogues about his rambles. His magnum opus backpacking manual was in its third version by the time I bought my first Frostfire II, and was filled with the best gear and advice from the late 1980s.

I devoured the Complete Walker III, reading it cover to cover and dog-earing page after page. One of the sections that intrigued me as I started to take my first winter camping trips was the description of vapor barrier systems.

The Backpacker’s Bible

The idea behind a vapor barrier is twofold. First, by encasing yourself in a fully waterproof, non-breathable envelope, you reduce evaporative cooling from perspiration. Second, by preventing perspiration from reaching your insulation you preserve its loft. Vapor barriers were touted as a way to extend the comfort range of sleeping bags, prevent your down bag from losing loft in winter, keep your boots from freezing, and eliminate insulating layers in a clothing system. They sounded downright miraculous.

But what about sweat? In theory, you were supposed to stop sweating after a while. The vapor barrier would create a moist microclimate next to skin which would trigger your body to stop producing “insensible perspiration” the kind of perspiration that happens all the time without us knowing it, just to keep our skin from drying out. You wouldn’t get really, really sweaty. Just a little bit damp. And it was worth it because you would be warmer with less insulation.

Vapor barrier shirts were, apparently, a thing. They would keep you warmer and would allow you to lighten your insulation load by leaving extra clothing at home. Proponents of vapor barrier clothing noted that under heavy exertion you would still perspire, and recommended zippers to vent vapor barrier tops when you were working hard.

Vapor barrier liners for sleeping bags were essentially coated nylon bags that you crawled into with your long underwear on. Vapor barrier socks were coated nylon bags for your feet to be worn over thin, synthetic liner socks.

Coated bags all around.

The foundation of my VB experiment looked a lot like this.

Being one to experiment, and being 19, I thought all these ideas were super duper interesting. So I set to work putting together a clever vapor barrier system that would give me maximum versatility in the field. I sewed a pair of pit zips into a lightweight, non-breathable paddling jacket and matched it with a pair of coated rain pants. These, I reckoned, would allow me to wear the vapor barrier inside my down parka and pants and inside my Moonstone Liberty Ridge 5 degree down bag to push it into deep winter temps. My first real winter camping trip proved to be the test: a short weekend with Craig and John over New Years doing a ski traverse of the Sylvania Wilderness in northern Wisconsin.

The results? Not favorable.

Mistakes were made.

I skied in a pair of Gore-Tex bibs with just a long underwear top and vapor barrier on my torso. Carrying a pack with full winter gear I sweated like a wrestler trying to drop weight. At night we had trouble getting the Mountainshelter and wood stove working, and even under my parka and down pants I was freezing. I finally tucked into my bag, vapor barrier, parka, down pants and all, and shivered until I fell asleep.

I awoke stifling hot and drenched in sweat. The vapor barrier pants and top did an admirable job of trapping sweat close to my body, but that was compensated for by the amount of sweat that poured out of my head and feet (I didn’t have the socks yet). My sleeping bag was puffy in the middle and soaked at the head and feet. It was a miserable night.

As we skied out the next day, I abandoned the idea of vapor barriers forever. The day was sunny and bright, much warmer than the day before. I must have lost five pounds sweltering away under that paddling jacket. Nope. Vapor barriers were not for me. Terrible idea.

With one caveat.

I did eventually try vapor barrier socks. Black Diamond made a pair out of super lightweight coated ripstop, and I decided to give them a chance as a way to keep my leather tele boots from freezing overnight. I’m happy to say that vapor barrier socks work exactly as advertised. Worn over a thin synthetic liner they keep your feet warm and your boots dry. Your feet don’t feel particularly sweaty and the slippery fabric reduces friction in your boot, keeping blisters at bay. Vapor barrier socks work great! The rest of it? Not so much.

[If you want to try VB socks, Rab makes a pair. Or you can use turkey roasting bags. Wear a synthetic liner sock inside the VB socks with a wool sock over the top.]

Extreme Alpinism
Which brings us back to Doctor Doom. When Extreme Alpinism hit my mailbox I turned immediately to the section on clothing to see what this “pseudo vapor barrier” thing was all about. I had done a fair bit of research on the Protective Combat Uniform for my exploration of a Simple Clothing System for all outdoor conditions. In my reading I had seen a throwaway line here and there about wearing a wind layer deep inside a fully-breathable layering system for some reason or another. Web searches referred to this as a “semipermeable vapor barrier,” or “pseudo vapor barrier.” What gives?

Pseudo vapor barrier? Marmot DriClime Windshirt.

Turns out, as you would expect, something pretty clever. Here’s the full quote from Twight’s book:

–You will sweat in the mountains. Most of this moisture develops from overheating due to movement. And most occurs on your back, where no matter how breathable the shell, the closed-cell foam and pressure of the pack blocks moisture transfer to the outside, so your back gets soaked. What happens after removing the pack and allowing moisture transfer to proceed? Rapid evaporative cooling, or flash-off–the result of super-efficient fabrics wicking moisture away from the body.

You can slow this chilly process dramatically by wearing a semipermeable vapor barrier (such as a microfiber windshirt or a thin shirt like the Patagonia Zephur or Marmot Dri-Clime Windshirt) over thin synthetic long underwear. Used this way, these pieces create a microclimate close to the body, slowing evaporation while still allowing moisture to wick through the semipermeable layer. The shirt acts like a second skin. Once moisture passes beyond the second skin into whatever super-efficient transport fabric is worn over it, moisture can transfer swiftly to the outside without conducting rapid evaporative cooling to the body’s core.

Which is to say, when it’s cold, your windbreaker works best inside your layers, rather than over the top of them.

Light weight wind shells, a versatile option for adding warmth inside a layering system.

[Links to discussion of wind shells and the DriClime Windshirt here: Wind Shells DriClime Windshirt ]

PCU: The Movie
Twight expanded on the concept in a training video developed to explain the military’s new cold weather clothing system to the special operations community. I discussed the development of the PCU in the first installment of my Simple Clothing System series. Twight was instrumental in creating the new system, based on his experience as an alpinist and his role in developing Patagonia’s Regulator soft shell clothing lineup.

Be warned, the video comes across as little bit corny while trying very hard to be serious. That said, if you make your way through the whole thing you will pick up some excellent advice on cold weather comfort.

About 45 minutes into the video, Twight explains that the wind shirt can be worn over baselayer and under soft shell in milder conditions, or layered inside grid fleece or high-loft fleece in colder conditions. Used in this way it reduces evaporative cooling at the skin and slides smoothly within layers, improving mobility.

Huh. Guess I was doing it wrong.

I had been using my wind shells directly under a soft shell in very cold and windy conditions. Worn this way, the wind shell reduces wind penetration into all your insulating layers.

Twight says a better approach is to wear a wind shirt directly over your baselayer.

When you think about it, it really does make sense.

How It Works
The traditional vapor barrier shirt that I tried in my 20s was a disaster, but using a wind shirt inside a layering system to accomplish much of the same thing makes a lot of sense. Layered in this way, the wind shirt can act as a sort of variable vapor barrier that automatically adjusts breathability to conform to exertion level.

When you’re working hard and sweating, the lightweight wind shirt will eventually get saturated with moisture. Once wet, this thin layer will impede vapor transfer. This is something that manufacturers of Gore-Tex shells figured out sometime in the 90’s. The slick, taffeta linings of early jackets soaked up perspiration. Once they were wet, the breathability of the garment declined dramatically. This eventually led to the adoption of mesh liners for 2-layer waterproof breathable garments, and later, the adoption of 2.5 and 3-layer fabrics. I cover the differences between these fabrics in my article on rain shells.

Once your wind shell wets-out from perspiration, it acts like a vapor barrier. Moisture passes more slowly from the inside of the shell to the outside. This traps a warm microclimate next to your skin and prevents evaporative cooling. When you stop, the wind can penetrate into your air permeable insulation layers and begin to dry the wind shirt. As your wind layer dries, it allows better vapor transmission, which, in turn, allows your base layer to dry more quickly. But not so quickly that you get chilled. The wind shirt blocks enough wind to reduce the rapid evaporation that would happen if the wind was blowing straight through your clothing system and directly onto that baselayer. Things dry out, but they do it in a more controlled way. That keeps you warmer.

All of this works only if your clothing system is fully air-permeable. I discussed this concept in detail in my post on soft shells. A fully air-permeable system allows the dew point within your clothing to form a smooth temperature and moisture gradient from warm to cold and damp to dry. Non-permeable shells like waterproof-breathables create a sharp temperature and moisture gradient at the outer shell layer. This results in condensation or freezing within the shell, which further soaks your insulating layers.

Twight strongly advocates for a fully breathable system. You’re going to get wet, he says, so you might as well wear something that you know will dry out fast. Adding the wind shirt inside of the layering system helps to manage that drying for better comfort and warmth in cold conditions.

Windshirt or Wind Shirt?
In the quote above, Twight mentions both a thin microfiber wind shirt and the Marmot DriClime Windshirt. The PCU includes an unlined wind shirt. The DriClime Windshirt has a brushed polyester lining. What works best?

In my discussion of the DriClime Windshirt I came to the conclusion that this piece really fills the role of lightweight fleece within a layering system, albeit with much more wind resistance. The DriClime Windshirt is warmer than a standalone wind layer. Warmer under a soft shell and warmer still under grid fleece, high loft fleece or active insulation.

The standalone wind layer is more versatile. As discussed in this post on wind shells, in addition to cutting the wind it can act as sun and bug protection. It isn’t as warm, but it is more versatile.

If you’re going to have only one, and that is what the Simple Clothing System is all about, you’ll want to go with the standalone wind shell rather than the DriClime Windshirt.

If you have the budget and are curious about the DriClime Windshirt I highly encourage you to check one out. Especially for cold weather layering.

Don’t change layers. Dress in clothes to keep you comfortable while working hard and then layer OVER these at rest breaks with high loft puffy gear. Shown here, Black Diamond Stance Belay Parka, USGI ECWCS Level 7 pants.

The Action Suit
A final note on one of Twight’s fundamental principles of cold weather layering. The Action Suit.

The idea behind the Action Suit is that you should choose clothing layers that are appropriate for your expected level of exertion and plan on leaving them on. This concept grew out of the impracticability of stripping off layers to adjust insulation while climbing in high mountains. It’s better, says Twight, to suit up in layers that will keep you slightly cool while moving hard and then layer OVER these clothes with high loft synthetic insulation when you stop.

This turns the traditional idea of layering on its head. With traditional layering you fuss with the layers inside your shell. With the Action Suit you set it, and forget it.

Using the Action Suit you plan to be either Active, or Static. Active mode has you moving hard and generating heat. Static mode comes at rest breaks when you burrow into your puffy layers. This approach will keep you drier and more comfortable while on the move and will increase comfort and warmth while at rest.

Wearing a wind shirt deep inside your layering system works extremely well for this approach. It gives you a little more wind resistance and reduces evaporative cooling. You stay warmer with less on, which reduces the possibility of overheating from exertion.

Putting it Together
I spent a winter several years back experimenting with different layers and recording the results in terms of comfort and warmth, so I have a pretty good idea of what to wear depending on temperature and wind speed. One of the things that I noticed most was how much your level of exertion will dictate how warm you are in a given set of clothes. I know that sounds like common sense, but I was shocked at how much hotter I was Nordic skiing than hiking. There was a massive difference in warmth. Same thing with the wind. I hiked one day at about 20 degrees in base layer, grid fleece and soft shells. The wind blasted through my clothing and chilled me despite my fleece layers.

A wind shirt over my baselayer would have made a huge difference.

I look forward to playing around with the windshirt and Action Suit concepts the next time I find myself enjoying an extended winter visit to the Deep North. For the moment I’m limited by a climate in coastal Georgia that rarely dips below thirty degrees. Bummer. I hope that a few of my friends back in the Ancestral Homeland will pick up the baton, give this a try, and report back in the comments. Winter is almost here!

Thanks for reading. If you’d like to take a look at all the articles I’ve written on the Simple Clothing System you can find them here.

If you enjoyed this post, please consider subscribing to Kitchi-Gami.com by using one of the links in the menu on the right side of the screen. On your mobile device you’ll find the links if you scroll to the bottom of the page. Thanks!

6 thoughts on “A Simple Clothing System Supplemental: Wind Shells as Semipermeable Vapor Barriers”

  1. Illimani94's avatar Illimani94

    Hey Brian,

    I wanted to write you a longer response on this one because it pulls at a lot of threads in my outdoors layering thinking. Extreme Alpinism, and Will Gadd’s Ice and Mixed Climbing soon after, had a great influence on me as a middlin’ ice climber. Twight nails the limitations of waterproof/breathables for high-output sports, which caused me to look at microfiber and stretchwoven gear. I still have the Mammut softshell pants and Krushell/Ready Mix jackets I bought after reading the book. His Action Suit concept, that simple idea that you have two ranges of output: heat-producing action and low-energy rest changed everything that I found uncomfortable about ice climbing. Layer for the high-energy phase, throw on a big puffy when you stop – it seems so logical now, and was completely different from what I had been doing. I think his book influenced the lightweight backpacking community as well. If you’ve read Andrew Skurka you can sense the Extreme Alpinism influence as much as Ray Jardine’s. Hard to reconcile the young punk Twight that I met at the Wild Things shop in North Conway NH in the early ’80 with the systematic thinking behind this book and the PCU system, but I expect that could be said about any of us between our young and mature selves. Good on ya, Mark.

    One of my ice climbing friends illustrates the Action Suit principles perfectly. He layers: short-sleeve baselayer top and light baselayer bottoms; an old OR pullover stretchy windshirt; OR softshell hoody (Ferrosi) and Arc’teryx Alpha Comp pants. Any time he’s stopped he throws on this massive BD Primaloft parka. I’ve climbed with him on windy single-digit (F) days and he does just fine with this system.

    Vapor barriers. Like you I experimented in the ‘80s with this somewhat alien concept (remember the Stephensons Warmlite crew?) after reading The Complete Walker III. As part of a sleeping system I found a vapor barrier (I tried both a VB liner and VB jacket/pants) helped me sleep warmer and stay better hydrated overnight. My sleeping bag stayed drier as well, though that was only significant on multiday winter trips. Vapor barriers as part of my action layers? Fail, just as you described. There’s just too much variability in heat generation and convection loss. The boosters would always say that vapor barriers made you immediately aware of sweating and that you should adjust your venting and/or layering at that point. I never found it that straightforward.

    I’ve found two VBL garments that seem to work. First, as you noted, vapor barrier socks. Second, the vest made by 40 Below Limited with a vapor barrier back. Your back is going to get wet from a backpack, and the vest ensures that only your baselayer shirt gets wet by limiting moisture movement into the next layers. I find it works best with the old Lifa base layer stuff because it doesn’t wick very well; any moisture under the pack and VBL tends to stay there until it’s allowed to dry off.

    My experience with the idea of convection barriers has been generally better. A windshirt over a base layer top drastically reduces that chill feeling when you overheat due to working hard and then stop. I may be having a somewhat different experience from yours because the microfiber shells I use most often have lower air penetration than a true softshell outer. Also, my metabolism is such that it has to be really cold before I need more than a base layer and the DriClime under my shell.

    The whole thing is really subtle and elegant. The overall goal is to avoid moisture condensing in your clothing layers over the temperature gradient from inner to out layers. The Action Suit means you won’t sweat as much, and if you do the moisture is less likely to condense because there are fewer layers between you and the outer shell. Condensation against cold waterproof/breathable outer layers is well known, due to relatively low breathability. Microfber or softshell outers are way more breathable than Gore-Tex et. al., so less condensation there. Convection barriers manage the moisture by keeping it close to the body, releasing water vapor at a slower rate that doesn’t overwhelm the outer shell layer. And finally you stop, throw a big cloud of Primaloft over all, and residual moisture migrates out of your Action Suit into the parka. That’s why parkas should have very breathable outer fabrics because at that final shell layer is where the temperature gradient is most likely to cause condensation of the moisture from inside. One of the alpine climbing operator mods is taking long rest breaks daytime – to brew up, rehydrate, refuel, rest… Not only is it warmer daytime but sun on a dark parka outer shell will help evaporate condensed moisture from just inside the shell, drying your Primaloft.

    Obviously, those of us not alpine climbing have more wiggle room (spare base layers anyone? An actual tent for sleeping?), and hot tenting completely changes the dynamic. Still, Twight’s principles are worth keeping in mind. Anyone who XC skis knows the ritual of dressing for the dinking around at the car, charging off up the trail, and stopping 10 minutes in – wildly overheated, desperately shedding layers, inner layers already damp with sweat… You don’t have to live like this.

    A gear note. Have you tried any of Patagonia’s Nano Air gear? Last year I bought one of the Nano Air Ultralight pullovers. In use it seemed about the warmth of a grid fleece, like my R1 Flash pullover, but with the added convection barrier effects of the Airshed outer fabric. Worn under a softshell pullover I found it warmer than the R1 for that reason. After reading your post on the DriClime windshirt earlier this year I realized that Patagonia had, through convergent evolution, created an expensive alternate to the DriClime. The old Marmot piece does basically the same job. Yes, the Nano Air Ultralight has a better pocket and better collar, but functionally? Doing the same job and simpler in the bargain. Can we get a DriClime update, Marmot?

    1. Wow! Thanks for the great comment!

      I haven’t tried the Nano Air gear. I ordered a vest a couple seasons back but the large was so tight I sent it back. And didn’t order an XL to replace it because it seemed so thin. I would definitely consider adding a vest to my gear closet to swap out in place of the R2 vest that’s part of my layering system now.

      I do have one of the Polartec Alpha 3A jackets that Patagonia made for the PCU and I like it a lot. It’s air permeable enough that it dries very quickly. And it’s plenty warm. Great under soft shell.

      My understanding of Nano Air is that it is similar to other active insulation pieces in allowing excellent moisture transfer and drying quickly. It does not actively wick moisture tho. Which has me leaning more toward R1 over Driclime Windshirt rather than Nano Air, with a Nano Air or similar vest as my additional layer for deep cold.

      Like you, I run pretty warm and would rarely need this if I’m active.

      Having watched the PCU video a couple times, my thoughts are evolving on how the midweight insulating layer should be used in a layering system. I’m increasingly convinced that it is just too warm and not wicking enough to really work well as part of the Action Suit and it is really best thought of as light insulation for temperate conditions. Spring/Fall when you don’t need the big puffy layer. My field tests a few years back point in this direction, too. That 3A layer is too warm if I’m working. Better to leave it at home in the winter.

      VBL back on a vest seems interesting. Funny that the old Smelly Hellys seem to work best for you. Impressed that you still have a set!

      Marmot does offer a new top that seems Driclime-ish. Altho closer to Nano Air in terms of warmth. See my comment above for a link.

      Like you, I met Twight “back in the day” at OR. I was working for Lowe as a rep and he was still on board as an athlete and technical advisor. Very nice guy. I had no idea who he was at the time!

      I’m still a Driclime believer. Looking forward to getting back up north at some point to play an experiment in the snow.

      1. Illimani94's avatar Illimani94

        Patagonia can have sizing, uh, issues. I bought a Nano Air Light vest in size L, and also found it a close fit. For my purpose that was acceptable, but it’s interesting that a Nano Air Ultralight pullover in size L is a comfortable fit. I used to have a size XL Nano Air Light hoody, and that was way oversize. Same experience with the Airshed windshirts… I’m not sure if this is production variation or they subtly change the sizing year by year… BTW, the Ultralight pullover is way overbuilt; why does it need a chest pocket AND handwarmer pockets? Pick a lane…

        I always thought the Nano Air gear, like Arc’teryx’s Proton series, was intended to be a combo of midlayer and outer shell – warm enough over a baselayer and wind-resistant enough to not require a shell layer in many conditions. And on that point it mostly fails for me. The Airshed fabric seems damage-prone – something I don’t want happening to an expensive garment. The hoods are never as good as an actual shell’s hood. And mostly the garments have just been too warm for me. That Nano Air LIGHT hoody? I could wear it over a baselayer at 10F and be comfortable on the move. The Ultralight feels like a more usable insulation; perhaps I should try getting the hoody version of that. Worn under a softshell jacket that might be just enough insuation. Anyway, once you’ve reached the thinness of Ultralight, something like the DriClime is less expensive and more survivable, and doing more-or-less the same job.

        Lifa. Yes, the remaining 2 shirts are getting a bit scratchy, but still functional. They work well under the VB vest and a pack because they don’t try to wick moisture around; the wet stays confined to my back, so the VB vest keeps the next layer dry.

      2. Agreed. Their sizing can be all over the place. I have trouble with sleeves being too tight and have needed to go up a size in some cases. And I’ve seen a lot of shredded Nano Airs.

        Honestly, I don’t really get the Nano Air. As you said, they bill it as an insulation plus shell layer but it won’t hold up to that.

        And Patagonia has discontinued their stretch woven soft shell and really fragmented what was a really coherent layering system with Regulator.

        If it’s good, they’ll get rid of it.

Leave a Reply